| reporting the edge | credits | |
home
|
about
|
news
|
contents
|
gossip
|
photographs
|
venues
|
brighton
|
dublin
|
edinburgh
|
film
|
features
|
interviews
|
awards
|
fashion
|
recipes
|
no more drinks
|
newsletter
|
links
|
contact
Latest items? Unedited? Fringe Report Uncut
The Shaftas
Verdict: Sketch comedy
[Note - this review is based on seeing the first part of the show on Thursday 19 August and the second part on Friday 20 August. This was caused by the show starting (and perhaps ending) 25 minutes late on 19 August. The company explains that this was due to the overrunning of a previous show at the venue. According to the company the intended running times are: Part One (0:55); interval; Part Two (0:35); and the content of the respective parts is identical on both nights]
The premise is to parody the British Academy of Film and Television Arts (BAFTA) Awards. Sketches are presented by [British television celebrity compere] Terry Wogan's less-talented fictitious brother, Nigel Wogan (Nigel Quinn) and introduced by an array of poorly-imitated and mocked celebrities who include: Paris Hilton (Wendy Thomson), Sarah Palin (Una Carr) and Prince Charles (Oli Stephens).
However, the slick, cynical deadpan of the real-life Terry Wogan is replaced by Nigel Quinn's pondering delivery; lacking in energy, conviction and humour. Writing is hackneyed; performance is lacklustre. 'Let's interview the red carpet', this Wogan mutters nasally into his poorly-set-up radio microphone, complete with crackle. The interview is of the actual carpet. Jokes about enjoying celebrities wearing kilts set the puerile tone. Wogan points out the very apparent ruse that was being had: 'I'm sure I said "On the red carpet".'
The award for Best Documentary follows. Perhaps the highlight of this section is Oli Stephens's Spring Watch. He watches his giant spring with an animated, wide-eyed conviction which does the sketch justice. What a pity that his talent is wasted on such unoriginal material. The cleverest line of this first category comes in a song about the [British Parliamentary] Expenses Scandal. Tuneless singing it may be, typical late-night karaoke stuff, but the tasteless gem 'I'll buy a brand new tie and put it on expense / fly her in from Bangkok it all makes sense' encourages a groan if not a smile.
Wendy Thomson's Paris Hilton has apt wig and miniature dog, but the impression is terrible, with slip-sliding American accent, and the lack of any apparent point to the skit (there are no comical lines at all). Oli Stephens's crass impression of Prince Charles feels similarly pointless; and he has neither wig nor costume, happens to be bald, and looks nothing like the future UK King. The material parodies British TV, and is no worse and no better than stuff on British TV on a very bad day. The difference is that the delivery from all performers lacks confidence, conviction, timing, presence. Best efforts come from Louise Croombs when playing [British comedian] Russell Brand, and Una Carr as Lady Saga. But changing popular song lyrics to mock performers has to be done extremely well to work, and here it is done awfully badly. What is more incongruous (in this example) is that Russell Brand has nothing to do with [British singer] Beyonce's (Should Have) Put A Ring On It.
One glimmer is a sketch by Ian Holgate. It shows him, if not a brilliant comic, a very able beat poet with a great sense of rhythm and of irony. His homage to Trainspotting's Choose Life is surprising. Ian Holgate has been a hidden diamond so far in the show, the only member of the cast with a natural sense of timing and a comical and expressive demeanour. Here he come into his own with a slick and clever rap; a whistle-stop tour of all the pointless little bits and pieces that make up modern living. Though he leaves longer pauses than perhaps there should be in a couple of places, there is nothing an hour's re-looking at his script couldn't solve.
It is not enough to redeem the first half of this show. An hour has passed, a very long hour. And there is still forty minutes to go.
[Note - Part Two is seen on the following night by a different reviewer as explanatory note above]
Part Two has sketches which parody shows and people including: [the West German Cellar Murderer] Josef Fritzl & [the British TV house makeover show] Changing Rooms; a character called Cock Au Vin; Britain's Best Grub ('tastes like a tramp's penis'); [British TV] Faking It ('You can put a pig in a dress but she's always going to grunt'); Jeremy Vile [TV Jeremy Kyle Show]; [British TV chef] Gordon Ramsay's Dating Nightmares; How To Turn A Ladette Into A Lady (quite good performance of Ladette song); Grim Reaper coming for [singers] Stephen Gately & Michael Jackson (song with Death and chorus quite good); an Entertainment Award segment with Batman trying to find a new Robin; [TV hypnotist] Paul McKenna; and more,including [British TV] The Apprentice, Britain's Got Talent
Comments on Part Two: same as for Part One above. It is difficult to see where the balance of the show's present difficulties lie between performance and script. Although the performers clearly put in a lot of effort, almost all of the writing feels very unfunny at the moment; and this in turn suppresses possible talent in performance.
Cast Credits: MC: Nigel Quinn – Nigel Wogan. (Cast in alpha order, each also plays other characters): Una Carr – Lady Saga / Petula / Sarah Palin / Jilly Goolden. Louise Croombs – Russell Brand / Death / Gordon Ramsay / Jeremy Clarkson. Ian Holgate – Justin Lee Collins / Susan Boyle / Jonathan Ross / Jeremy Vile. Oli Stephens – Donut McIntyre / Prince Charles / Mary / Batman. Wendy Thomson – Paris Hilton / Lady Gaga / Davina McCall / Simon Cowell.
Company Credits: Writers (alpha order): Louise Croombs, Charlotte De'allie, Ian Holgate, Dominic Hood, Oli Stephens, Wendy Thomson. Director - Louise Croombs. Lighting Designer - uncredited. Sound Designer - uncredited. Technical Operator - uncredited. Script Editor - Oli Stephens. Photographer - David Greaves. Graphic Designer - John Mullaney. Sound Technician - Kevin Croombs. Cameraman - Alex Thomson. Producer - Wendy Thomson. Company - The Reading Berks. Website - www.thereadingberks.co.uk.
END
(c) Rebecca Gibson 2010
(with additional notes on Part Two by John Park)
reviewed Thursday 19 August 2010 (first part, seen by Rebecca Gibson) & Friday 20 August 2010 (second part, seen by John Park) / Phoenix Artist Club, London UK
Fringe Report (c) Fringe Report 2002-2012